Friday, June 27, 2025
Home Most Popular FMC dismisses complaint about MSC’s congestion surcharge

FMC dismisses complaint about MSC’s congestion surcharge

The US Federal Maritime Commission (FMC) has dismissed a shipper’s complaint that a US$1,000 congestion surcharge imposed by Mediterranean Shipping Company (MSC) was an unjust detention and demurrage charge.

This was because the surcharge was not a detention and demurrage charge at all.

On 3 February, US-based SOFi Paper Products, which had booked its shipment through an NVOCC, filed its complaint, seeking a refund of the congestion surcharge and alleging that the surcharge contravened the US Shipping Act as MSC did not justify it.

MSC’s initial response was that it was not the proper party in the proceeding, as the Swiss/Italian liner giant did not transact directly with SOFi, and that the NVOCC was its actual customer.

However, the FMC ruled that MSC acted as the ocean common carrier with respect to SOFi’s shipment, and was thus, the proper respondent.

On 13 February, MSC sent SOFi a cheque to refund the US$1,000.

All but one of the FMC commissioners threw out SOFi’s complaint, as unlike detention and demurrage charges, which are imposed when containers remain at a terminal after a complimentary period, the congestion surcharge did not fall under this description.

Delivering its ruling on 29 September, FMC said, “The amount of demurrage and detention charges, including ‘per diem’, generally depends on the length of the use of space or containers after the free time. It does not appear, however, that the assessment of the congestion surcharge depended on the expiration of any free time. Rather than specific use of land or containers, it appears that the congestion surcharge was assessed for each container with respect to the overall flow of transportation.”

As MSC had returned the US$1,000 to SOFi, the refund demand was moot.


Martina Li
Asia Correspondent





Latest Posts

Saudi Arabia port agreements suggest strategic commitment despite regional turmoil

Saudi Arabia has signed long-term port concession agreements worth over $586 million with two major global operators. Beyond infrastructure, this deal sends a powerful signal:...

Trump’s icebreaker gambit: US sets course for Arctic power play against Russia

In a move that could reshape Arctic geopolitics and redefine shipping lanes for decades, former US President Donald Trump revealed that he has offered...

Port of Barcelona strengthens position as investment magnet with new agreements

Port of Barcelona Management Board has approved four strategic initiatives to enhance competitiveness, expand logistics capacity, advance sustainability, and modernize facilities. At first, Terminal Investments...

Global bunker prices on downward trend

Global bunker indices tracked by Marine Bunker Exchange (MABUX) fell sharply in the 26th week of the year, driven by expectations that a ceasefire...

Mawani signs privatization contracts for cargo terminals at eight Saudi ports

In a major step toward advancing Saudi Arabia’s logistics infrastructure, the Saudi Ports Authority (Mawani) has signed privatization contracts for multipurpose cargo terminals at...
error: Content is protected !!